From the 101 lk/man/pth code-gen sources: 63 tasks (C11 36, C++17 27, 11 canonical families), 38 skipped for scope or duplication. Each task has at least one independent contract-edge defect, boundary types rotate, and public docs state trap clauses as plain contract prose. Claude reviewed 63/63 USABLE against current digests. Difficulty is unmeasured. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
117 lines
14 KiB
Markdown
117 lines
14 KiB
Markdown
# 任务规格:concur-batch-commit-tail
|
||
|
||
## 1. 身份与来源
|
||
|
||
| 字段 | 填写 |
|
||
| --- | --- |
|
||
| task-id / 任务版本 | concur-batch-commit-tail / 1 |
|
||
| 作者 / 业务评审人 / 独立评审人 | batch22 pth-cond-group-commit 子Agent / root待审 / root待审 |
|
||
| 审核状态 | CALIBRATED;难度UNMEASURED |
|
||
| 原项目与冻结版本 | HWE本地批次20261027-C-hwe-hard-22只读材料;原始指纹见本题root-source-review.json |
|
||
| 来源路线 | C 素材写题;原创修复工程,不声称历史现场故障 |
|
||
| 来源ID | hwe/pth-cond-group-commit |
|
||
| 来源与授权 | 用户2026-10-27批次BRIEF;metadata visibility=public;只读metadata、prompt与reference,未读checks或执行来源脚本 |
|
||
| 隐私处理 | 无真实用户内容或凭据 |
|
||
| 替身测试 | software:显式调用表达调度账本,无真实线程、时间、硬件、特权或外部服务 |
|
||
| split分组键 | pth-cond-group-commit |
|
||
| 来源组 / 根因族 | HWE cond-group-commit / linux-concurrency |
|
||
| 与已有任务关系 | 原创的批量发布与尾批模型;来源与ID初筛由root核对,无共用其他新题业务骨架 |
|
||
| 验证范围 | C++17公开账本、backend、helper的确定性行为与文本域 |
|
||
| 未验证范围 | 真实线程调度、pthread原语实现、硬件、模型能力及真实Agent轨迹 |
|
||
|
||
设计动机:把原料的“攒满N再提交”改写为可以逐条重放与复算的生产者/提交者软件账本。队列由Engine维护,发布由独立Journal完成,policy决定谓词可选数量,text独立解析配置。原料代码不复制进工程。
|
||
|
||
缺陷一:policy.cpp的take_count在closing且queued<width时返回0,Engine::pump因此留住最后未满批记录并一直返回WAIT,status.ready也同源错误。指定精确合同边界类型为“最后不满批次的精确收尾”;公开依据R08,smoke不覆盖这一边界。
|
||
|
||
缺陷二:journal.cpp的新ticket在检查故障注入前已经插入发布记录。Engine收到-11仍保留队列与ticket,而Journal的published计数提前变化。涉及Journal提交与Engine重试两个模块,报告来自console;公开smoke可独立复现。
|
||
|
||
只修tail保留提前发布,only_fix_tail在smoke与template一致;只修publish保留尾批等待,only_fix_publish在private-tail与template一致。二者独立对照保存在本题factory/selftest。公开文档按2026-10-27 plain-docs要求使用普通条款,不标出陷阱或给边界专门举例。
|
||
|
||
## 2. 初态与环境
|
||
|
||
- 初态资产:template的group.hpp、policy.cpp、text.cpp、journal.cpp、engine.cpp、console.cpp、Makefile、smoke.txt、README.md、docs/contract.md及docs/console.md。所有源码与输入随题公开;没有遗漏的依赖文件。
|
||
- 公开资产:完整工程、R01–R17合同、命令/结果字段、公开smoke。候选只交付五个声明文件。template不含答案、隐藏输入、spec、历史或构建产物。
|
||
- 受保护资产:check.py、gold及fixture、spec与校准证据。verify.py逐字复制rollout/bos_verify.py。
|
||
- 环境族:固定trace6 Linux runtime,C++17及Python 3;离线使用g++和标准库,无额外依赖或服务。
|
||
- 镜像引用:ccr-29eug8s3-pub.cnc.bj.baidubce.com/algo/bench-runtime@sha256:1519f8daa403998e5401eeb70b973e8aac8346e25a937033bc502dc5de1641a1。实际image ID由正式receipt记录。
|
||
- 资源:正式评分512MiB/1CPU;check内编译35秒、观察20秒;平台总评分120秒。执行超时只防挂死。
|
||
- 本题C++/头文件独有非空无注释行720,按template单份统计,包含491行可提交实现和229行独立观察控制台。fixture复制不计入。各文件细分与去注释算法见本题report/selfcheck记录。
|
||
- 外部依赖:无。初态行为见本题factory/selftest内template-public-smoke.stdout和template-private-tail.stdout;不将本地受信执行当不可信隔离证据。
|
||
|
||
## 3. 公开题面与接口
|
||
|
||
题面为中文现场报告式描述,见prompt.md:操作返回可重试而报告已发布记录先变化;make smoke复现;要求满足docs/contract.md全部条款并提交五个声明文件。没有点名根因函数/文件/类别。
|
||
|
||
公开构建argv为["make"],执行argv为["./group-console"]并从stdin读取命令。成功运行退出0,非法控制台命令退出2。stdout是JSON数组原始观察;语义按整数比较,可容许JSON空白差异,bool不视为整数。stderr仅供诊断,不限制大小或字节编码。完整API参数、返回、副作用、输出引用、顺序和边界见R01–R17;console字段在docs/console.md。
|
||
|
||
## 4. 判据检查项 ↔ 依据与合法解
|
||
|
||
| 判据检查项 | 公开依据 | 输入/场景 | 可观察结果与方法 | 公开/受保护 | 超时 |
|
||
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
|
||
| R01 Independent Engines/Journals and unchanged inputs | template/docs/contract.md:3 | Interleaved objects and every text/batch helper | U alternation and independent raw byte/item digests; exact integer fields | private inputs / public rule | 20s process |
|
||
| R02 Return values and WAIT/DONE observations | template/docs/contract.md:5 | Inactive, malformed, range, full, conflict, retry, idle and done | Typed integer array comparison; exact integer fields | private inputs / public rule | 20s process |
|
||
| R03 All out fields and state retained on errors | template/docs/contract.md:7 | pump/peek/read/parse/config/commit failures | Nonces 0, intermediate, uint64 max; before/after status; exact integer fields | private inputs / public rule | 20s process |
|
||
| R04 Configuration domains, reconfiguration and reset | template/docs/contract.md:9 | width 0/1/16/17/MAX, capacities below/equal/64/65 | V direct helper and C/Z sequences; exact integer fields | private inputs / public rule | 20s process |
|
||
| R05 Inactive checks precede remaining validation | template/docs/contract.md:11 | unconfigured enqueue/fail/pump/peek/read/close | Malformed inactive operations plus status; exact integer fields | private inputs / public rule | 20s process |
|
||
| R06 Ordered queue, lifetime ids and admission checks | template/docs/contract.md:13 | full queues, invalid fields, duplicates before/after pump and close | Q and receipts plus status; exact integer fields | private inputs / public rule | 20s process |
|
||
| R07 Closing generation and replaceable failure setting | template/docs/contract.md:15 | empty/full queues, repeated close, invalid replacement | X/X, F 0..9/MAX, P then S; exact integer fields | private inputs / public rule | 20s process |
|
||
| R08 Batch width, final partial group and one-group pump | template/docs/contract.md:17 | width 1/2/3/4/7/16; 0, width-1,width,width+1,2width±1,64 Items | Independent K matrix; engine prefix and completion observations; exact integer fields | private inputs / public rule | 20s process |
|
||
| R09 Atomic failure and idempotent ticket publication | template/docs/contract.md:19 | failure 0/2/8, repeated/conflicting/reordered tickets and retries | JC/JS/JR direct backend; Engine P/S/R; exact integer fields | private inputs / public rule | 20s process |
|
||
| R10 Batch validation, value domain and duplicate ids | template/docs/contract.md:21 | empty/17 Items, invalid ticket/id/value and mixed-error batches | B independently and JC while failures are pending; exact integer fields | private inputs / public rule | 20s process |
|
||
| R11 Publication indexing and queued indexing | template/docs/contract.md:23 | first/last/outside/MAX indexes, reads after close/reset | JR/R/Q with multiple initial output patterns; exact integer fields | private inputs / public rule | 20s process |
|
||
| R12 Summary, same_items and modulo total | template/docs/contract.md:25 | empty, 1,16,17,64 Items, full uint64 fields, order/value/id changes | D/E independently of Journal and Engine; exact integer fields | private inputs / public rule | 20s process |
|
||
| R13 Item digest byte layout and empty digest | template/docs/contract.md:27 | asymmetric ids/values, maximum words, repeated records | H direct helper and independent Python FNV arithmetic; exact integer fields | private inputs / public rule | 20s process |
|
||
| R14 Full status, counters and instance isolation | template/docs/contract.md:29 | initial, admitted, attempted, committed, failed, reused and reset | S/JS after commands; exact integer fields | private inputs / public rule | 20s process |
|
||
| R15 Decimal grammar, lexical-before-range and output retention | template/docs/contract.md:31 | empty/sign/SP/TAB/CR/LF/VT/FF/NUL/non-ASCII, overflow plus trailing invalid byte | N direct helper with original-input digests; exact integer fields | private inputs / public rule | 20s process |
|
||
| R16 Complete config grammar and numeric validation | template/docs/contract.md:33 | ordering, separators, whitespace, mixed errors, overflow, complete-line trailing bytes | T direct helper with original-input digests; exact integer fields | private inputs / public rule | 20s process |
|
||
| R17 Unbounded leading-zero strings and raw diagnostics | template/docs/contract.md:35 | Whole strings transported as hex, strict stdout UTF-8, stderr replacement decode | 20,000 leading zeros and overflowing numeric tokens; exact integer fields | private inputs / public rule | 20s process |
|
||
| 控制台观察格式与输入内容保留 | template/docs/console.md:3,5,7,9,11,13,15,17,19,21 | 所有命令、同进程U双实例、独立helper与Journal操作 | 固定原始观察器只输出实值;Python独立建模并严格整数语义比较 | public protocol / private script | 20s |
|
||
| 编译与交付边界 | prompt.md:5;template/README.md:7 | 五个声明文件重新构建 | 私有固定console与候选源码编译,其他文件不收集 | public | 35s |
|
||
|
||
- Oracle以Python重新实现公开数学与状态合同,不执行gold获取答案。固定seed 0xBA7C22用于700步交错回归。每次生成同样的完整输入,所有输出字段都比较。
|
||
- 所有候选文件先一次性读取,mkdtemp(dir=Path.cwd())下写好全部源码,再启动首个child;之后check不遍历、读、写或清理共享scratch。平台外层root最终统一回收。无候选同进程导入、ctypes或shell执行;harness无断言或预期结果。
|
||
- stdout以bytes捕获后按UTF-8/JSON解码;stderr只诊断时以replace解码。JSON递归同类型比较,拒绝bool冒充整数。原始observer独立计算输入指纹,不借用被测helper计算其输入是否改变。
|
||
- 合法替代解valid_cow使用deque队列、unordered_set接受索引、Journal整份新状态写时复制后swap,选择数量采用整除计算;与gold的vector/线性搜索/原地append不同。
|
||
- 拒绝硬编码公开批宽、忽略失败设置、输出PASS替代行为等捷径;不要求候选使用特定调用路径。每个公开helper均通过直接原始观察验证,Journal也独立于Engine验证。cheat_read_grader仅核对判据隔离。
|
||
- grader的输出由统一verify包装器提供一行JSON;PASS/FAIL检查数1,退出0/1;缺环境或执行故障另按平台合同,不计能力失败。
|
||
- 隐藏输入、答案及历史候选不提供给Agent;没有发布到Salty的历史答案或任何外挂检索依赖。
|
||
|
||
## 5. 四类样例与校准
|
||
|
||
| 样例 | 预期 | 检验目的 |
|
||
| --- | --- | --- |
|
||
| gold | PASS | 满足全部公开合同 |
|
||
| template | FAIL | 两处独立缺陷初态 |
|
||
| only_fix_tail | FAIL | 仅修尾批,保留失败提前发布 |
|
||
| only_fix_publish | FAIL | 仅修失败发布,保留尾批等待 |
|
||
| noop | FAIL | configure修改状态后返回未配置,破坏核心功能 |
|
||
| cheat | FAIL | 按公开smoke的固定批宽4处理所有参数 |
|
||
| mask_symptom_retry | FAIL | 忽略失败注入掩盖公开症状 |
|
||
| valid_cow | PASS | 不同队列、索引与事务提交结构 |
|
||
| cheat_read_grader | FAIL(Docker) | 判据隔离;本地可读而PASS为合同允许例外 |
|
||
|
||
现成两门均每类5次,共45次;不降低每类次数,不改平台。最终回执及任务摘要由本题report.json记录,不手写或修改回执。若本地reader PASS导致总门FAIL,保留真实原件并注明允许例外,以Docker整体PASS为正式校准结果。最终校准前删除template构建产物并冻结任务摘要。
|
||
|
||
## 6. 真实试采与证据
|
||
|
||
- 本批不用Qwen或其他额外模型;未做真实Agent采样,没有原生轨迹、broker对账、模型成功率或难度分池结论。
|
||
- 任务状态只能为CALIBRATED/UNMEASURED;不能宣称HARD、ADMITTED或真实调度/硬件通过。
|
||
- 本次唯一运行证据在runs/20261027-C-hwe-hard-22/pth-cond-group-commit。每次attempt唯一,不覆盖历史;环境异常立即停止本题精确PID并报root。
|
||
- 容器由平台逐个管理并核对cleanup;不清理其他作业。没有本题专属网络、外部服务或凭据。尚未封存或上传Salty,收尾由root统一安排。
|
||
|
||
## 7. 评审与准入
|
||
|
||
- [x] 来源、公开机制、软件替身、完整初态与交付边界已核对。
|
||
- [x] 全部17条公开合同以及固定observer输出均建立依据映射;未为边界条款加提示。
|
||
- [x] 正例、结构不同正例、定向修复负例和症状遮盖样例齐全;本题预检与缺陷独立对照保留真实输出。
|
||
- [x] 最终双门回执摘要一致且Docker全部45次符合预期、cleanup confirmed;本地reader PASS例外使原始整体FAIL,原件保留。
|
||
- [ ] root只读独审完成。
|
||
- [ ] 真实采样和难度测量(本批明确不做)。
|
||
|
||
作者自检:2026-10-27;未发现需要用户补充的材料或环境依赖。最终状态与根审结果以report/review为准,不在此宣称已准入。任务包发生变化后须重新两门校准。
|
||
|
||
最终校准记录(2026-10-27):任务摘要 `7e997b5270fd31dd896fa191e711732d5a1ae5d37d3dc767b6def2a5795ee0dd`。本地原始FAIL(仅许可reader例外),正式Docker PASS,各类5次。
|
||
|
||
- local: `runs/20261027-C-hwe-hard-22/pth-cond-group-commit/local-final-2c39d6b931274b74b2724c3db5ab028f/calibration-636db7df601f49e586492faab646363e`;cleanup confirmed。
|
||
- docker: `runs/20261027-C-hwe-hard-22/pth-cond-group-commit/docker-final-db4f5b3fd35d4d8495933d4902f31824/calibration-02955503f71e4b67a7fe62cf97946196`;cleanup confirmed。
|