Implementation baseline: ee2e355b. Current branch: feature/local-dev-toolkit. Full final review compares this baseline to final HEAD.
Ruling: Implement the eight newly published workspace-layout tickets, not repeat the eleven completed keyboard tickets — the user referenced the previous count while asking to execute the current tickets — if wrong, a separately scoped additional task may be needed.
Ruling: Work in the current clean feature checkout — the explicitly invoked implement skill requires commits on the current branch and this checkout owns the local verification stack — if wrong, later isolation would require moving local commits.
Ruling: Use ee2e355b as the final code-review fixed point — it is the recorded implementation-start HEAD immediately after all eight tickets were published — if wrong, a broader historical review would need a different baseline.
## Preflight: individual tickets
| Task | Internal consistency |
|---|---|
| 1 | Published behavior, dependency and browser/API acceptance agree; no source-string tests required. |
| 2 | Published behavior, dependency and browser/API acceptance agree; no source-string tests required. |
| 3 | Published behavior, dependency and browser/API acceptance agree; no source-string tests required. |
| 4 | Published behavior, dependency and browser/API acceptance agree; no source-string tests required. |
| 5 | Published behavior, dependency and browser/API acceptance agree; no source-string tests required. |
| 6 | Published behavior, dependency and browser/API acceptance agree; no source-string tests required. |
| 7 | Published behavior, dependency and browser/API acceptance agree; no source-string tests required. |
| 8 | Published behavior, dependency and browser/API acceptance agree; no source-string tests required. |
## Preflight: shared surfaces
| Pair | Producer / consumer and finding |
|---|---|
| 1 / 2 | Task 1 supplies focused/legacy presentation identity and stable session boundary; later layout changes must not remount editing state. No conflicting requirement found. |
| 1 / 3 | Task 1 supplies focused/legacy presentation identity and stable session boundary; later layout changes must not remount editing state. No conflicting requirement found. |
| 1 / 4 | Task 1 supplies focused/legacy presentation identity and stable session boundary; later layout changes must not remount editing state. No conflicting requirement found. |
| 1 / 5 | Task 1 supplies focused/legacy presentation identity and stable session boundary; later layout changes must not remount editing state. No conflicting requirement found. |
| 1 / 6 | Task 1 supplies focused/legacy presentation identity and stable session boundary; later layout changes must not remount editing state. No conflicting requirement found. |
| 1 / 7 | Task 1 supplies focused/legacy presentation identity and stable session boundary; later layout changes must not remount editing state. No conflicting requirement found. |
| 1 / 8 | Task 1 produces behavior and evidence; task 8 consumes it for full workflow verification, not deferred implementation. No conflicting requirement found. |
| 2 / 3 | Task 2 establishes shared video/timeline/editor regions; later changes consume this stable geometry without replacing media/session state. No conflicting requirement found. |
| 2 / 4 | Task 2 establishes shared video/timeline/editor regions; later changes consume this stable geometry without replacing media/session state. No conflicting requirement found. |
| 2 / 5 | Task 2 establishes shared video/timeline/editor regions; later changes consume this stable geometry without replacing media/session state. No conflicting requirement found. |
| 2 / 6 | Task 2 establishes shared video/timeline/editor regions; later changes consume this stable geometry without replacing media/session state. No conflicting requirement found. |
| 2 / 7 | Task 2 establishes shared video/timeline/editor regions; later changes consume this stable geometry without replacing media/session state. No conflicting requirement found. |
| 2 / 8 | Task 2 produces behavior and evidence; task 8 consumes it for full workflow verification, not deferred implementation. No conflicting requirement found. |
| 3 / 4 | Existing task/session state and presentation identity remain shared; execute sequentially and retain prior task regressions. No conflicting requirement found. |
| 3 / 5 | Existing task/session state and presentation identity remain shared; execute sequentially and retain prior task regressions. No conflicting requirement found. |
| 3 / 6 | Existing task/session state and presentation identity remain shared; execute sequentially and retain prior task regressions. No conflicting requirement found. |
| 3 / 7 | Viewport suspension wraps existing play/continuation boundaries independently of panel contents; delayed results must still reconcile. No conflicting requirement found. |
| 3 / 8 | Task 3 produces behavior and evidence; task 8 consumes it for full workflow verification, not deferred implementation. No conflicting requirement found. |
| 4 / 5 | Existing task/session state and presentation identity remain shared; execute sequentially and retain prior task regressions. No conflicting requirement found. |
| 4 / 6 | Existing task/session state and presentation identity remain shared; execute sequentially and retain prior task regressions. No conflicting requirement found. |
| 4 / 7 | Viewport suspension wraps existing play/continuation boundaries independently of panel contents; delayed results must still reconcile. No conflicting requirement found. |
| 4 / 8 | Task 4 produces behavior and evidence; task 8 consumes it for full workflow verification, not deferred implementation. No conflicting requirement found. |
| 5 / 6 | Existing task/session state and presentation identity remain shared; execute sequentially and retain prior task regressions. No conflicting requirement found. |
| 5 / 7 | Viewport suspension wraps existing play/continuation boundaries independently of panel contents; delayed results must still reconcile. No conflicting requirement found. |
| 5 / 8 | Task 5 produces behavior and evidence; task 8 consumes it for full workflow verification, not deferred implementation. No conflicting requirement found. |
| 6 / 7 | Viewport suspension wraps existing play/continuation boundaries independently of panel contents; delayed results must still reconcile. No conflicting requirement found. |
| 6 / 8 | Task 6 produces behavior and evidence; task 8 consumes it for full workflow verification, not deferred implementation. No conflicting requirement found. |
| 7 / 8 | Task 7 produces behavior and evidence; task 8 consumes it for full workflow verification, not deferred implementation. No conflicting requirement found. |
- Final report/manual: delivered; task reports,finalreviews,ledger archived under docs/verification/annotation-workspace-layout.
Task 1 fix round 1: reviewer requests behavioral stop-after-current preservation across toggles; /root/workspace_01 assigned scoped test addition. Controller independently verified baseline tag54a35afa and complete bundle (git bundle verify okay).
Ruling: Keep proportional timeline entries within each bounded four-item page and provide exact ordinal search/selection — the spec requires bounded accessible navigation, while existing duration/drag mapping must remain meaningful — if wrong, equal-width list cards would need an additional presentation surface; tiny entries must still be selectable through search and editable in the fixed editor.
Task 4 fix round 1: /root/review_workspace_04 found twoImportant: destination scope resets crossslice history target; pageedge drag clamp/rescale drift. /root/workspace_04 assigned reproduce/fix/browserregression before nextticket.
Native OS IME supplemental attempt: separate headed Edge draft-only window prepared; cua.getApp tool blocked for an abnormally long time and returned unrelated existing browser window. No native typing/input-source changes were performed. Own runner stopped; its browser had already closed. No native IME pass claimed. Avoid further desktop tool calls for this attempt.
Task6 fixround1: reviewer identifies inspection progress overlay atvideo bottom and original camera flags trapping hidden camera on return focused. /root/workspace_06 assigned reproduce/fix, realpicture occlusion checks and successful screenshots.
Browser zoom readiness independently proven in isolated persistent Edge profile via actual setDefaultZoom; see ignored zoom-readiness.md. No user browser profile modified.
Final verification started for unchanged backend surfaces: full Go source packages, Python in .venv, Rust offline. Logs and exit codes in local-data/verification/annotation-workspace-layout/final-checks. Sessions Go60933/Python48131/Rust84597. Frontend suite awaits Task07 product completion.
Additional create-once local fixtures: workspace-viewport-unknown (two unowned ready slices), workspace-viewport-generation (owned slice-primary), workspace-full-workflow (owned slice-primary plus two ready pool tasks, reserved for Task08). No previous task/evidence reset.
Root final backend checks completed: Go13 packages pass/2 no tests/60 existing API failures exact name set; Python648pass25fail3skip, no new failures vs prior25 (old json_to_csv cache failures absent); Rust25tests/lint/release pass; Go builds/script syntax pass; Go formatting existing single-file debt; K8s client discovery localhost8080 blocked,22 local YAML structures pass. Full-suite-status.md and final-checks comparison JSON retain evidence. Backup tag and complete bundle reverified successfully.
Task07 fix round1 dispatched /root/workspace_07: /root/review_workspace_07 actual browser RED delayed owned-pool GET switches completed annotate-primary to owned pool-01 while viewport suspended (no writes). Root agrees Important: owned lookup is not an allocated claim; defer opening next owned task until explicit Continue, retaining handoff intent. Existing in-flight actual claim reconciliation unchanged. Reviewer final report pending.
Task07 fix1 delivered972721e; scoped re-review /root/review_workspace_07. Real pool and summary delays independently RED→GREEN, both continuous/resume-only;0writes/claims,versions3/2 unchanged. Prior viewport suite/type/build pass after fix.
Task08 runtime assistance: fresh workspace-full-workflow2 created after runner seek-timing consumed initial fixtures; prior generated/submitted effects retained. Added two new local reviewer users with correct global quality_reviewer / acceptance_reviewer roles and copied12project memberships each, since snapshot fanyu-full-qc/acceptance are globally annotators. New ignored qc-reviewer-auth.json / acceptance-reviewer-auth.json mode0600; existing users/tasks untouched. Original QA/acceptance login200 but route redirects; opsadmin single known-password login401, no password changes.
Task08 implementation89c9e168, review /root/review_workspace_08. Important committed test-runner cleanup error independently confirmed: wrong annotate assertion before mutation, loop closed early and out-of-scope names. Fixround1 /root/workspace_08; fresh full-workflow4 prepared for runtimeRED(no writes,verifyv1) then finalcandidate completeGREEN. Earlier authoritative3-task evidence retained, never reset. Root archive initial20reports prepared; refresh after fixes/reviews.
Task08 fix1 runtime investigation: finalcandidate runner hash a20779d7c1187106f1f01e441574094bc19bc507964e82f9a78f5b8a14fa9f56; committedRED on fresh4 beforewrites verifiedv1. Generation later interrupted despite unchangedproductsource. Actual controlled Markdown append/restore each emitted ViteWSfull-reload→pagehide/navigation→explicitrecovery,0POST; rootonlydocwrites caused interference. API99553/Vite97816 unchanged, no restart. Coordinated ALL-file-write freeze; freshfull-workflow5 exactcandidate complete exit0,3generate/3save/3handoff/2successclaims/1empty, primaryv8 pools v9QA. Freeze ended afterexit; previousfull4v4 preserved. Fixcommit/report pending.
Ruling: Defer shared browser reachability-helper extraction — current independent acceptance runners passed and extraction would broaden final test changes without a product defect — if wrong, duplicated helpers may drift and need coordinated future updates.
Ruling: Defer centralized four-entry pagination policy — both current consumers agree on the accepted fixed page size, with actual cross-page evidence — if wrong, a future page-size change could miss a consumer until refactoring.
Ruling: Defer shared viewport-size predicate extraction — all current checks match and fresh dispatch-time reads protect races; no behavior defect was found — if wrong, a future minimum-size change could diverge until the checks are centralized.
Final whole-feature fixed HEADa313b22a, Standards1docviolation+3lowheuristics,Spec0. /root/workspace_final_docs_fix assigned sole documented violation.
Final root APIreadback: full-workflow5 primaryv8, pool02/pool01v9, allquality_review/ready. FinalSpec0,Standardsdocviolationclosed+3nonblockingadvisories. Localfeaturebranch preserved; no push/deploy/merge. Plan execution complete.
每项修复均有针对性的真实浏览器回归或持久化 API 回读,详细证据将在最终验收与审查报告中链接。完整测试中的既有失败单列于 [全仓测试结果](./full-suite-results.md)。
产品问题均有针对性的真实浏览器回归或持久化 API 回读;验收脚本修正版完成一轮完整真实流程。详细证据见[整体验收](./acceptance-results.md)与[最终审查](./final-review.md)。完整测试中的既有失败单列于 [全仓测试结果](./full-suite-results.md)。
`b83e810e` — `📋 Record resolved annotation workspace decisions`
The commit contains only `.scratch/annotation-workspace-layout/map.md`.
## Changes
- Marked tickets 01–08 as resolved and independently reviewed.
- Added one linked, concise result for each ticket, including its implementation and review-fix commit where applicable.
- Linked the operator manual, combined acceptance report, full-suite result, and execution record.
- Preserved the design and preview observations while labeling them as historical, and replaced obsolete present-tense claims about implementation, browser verification, the original workbench, and local 5173.
- Recorded the retained limits: native OS IME, physical display/OS-scale coverage, zero final-acceptance media members, and no push, deployment, or QA approval.
## Checks
- `git diff --check` passed before the commit.
- A local Markdown-link check verified all 18 links in `map.md` resolve.
- `git diff --cached --check` passed immediately before the commit.
- No browser run, company-service access, push, deployment, or QA approval was performed.
`docs/verification/annotation-workspace-layout/execution-record.md` was already modified in the working tree and was left unstaged and uncommitted.
Reviewed `ee2e355ba1838578b0611628bc764abbbeec6eef...a313b22ae824208feb9fc6ac30103b36c3325e65` against the layout specification, tickets 01–08, retained keyboard contract, CONTEXT.md and ADR-0001. Read the production diff, relevant browser runners, acceptance/manual/execution records and task evidence. No product, index or HEAD mutations; no browser or broad-suite rerun.
**Result: no confirmed actionable Spec findings.**
- **Missing/partial implementation:** none established. The shared mounted editor/session/media, account-local preference, original fallback, bounded timelines/dictionaries, fixed actions, camera inspection and undersized-window recovery implement the requested boundaries. Pending claim reconciliation remains distinct from deferred owned-task reads; explicit viewport continuation preserves stop/hard-pause intent.
- **Unrequested behavior/scope creep:** none established. No backend/schema/allocation changes; reviewer layout is excluded. Four-item proportional timelines and ordinal lookup follow the recorded execution decision.
- **Implemented-but-wrong behavior:** none established after independently checking interactions among history reveal, layout switching, media visibility, viewport suspension, in-flight responses and post-handoff continuation.
**Coverage limits, not proven defects:**
- Spec L09 says “Chinese input composition and native text undo continue to work” (`.scratch/annotation-workspace-layout/spec.md:130`). Native cut/undo and synthetic composition checks exist; native OS IME remains unverified, explicitly recorded at `docs/verification/annotation-workspace-layout/acceptance-results.md:25`.
- Spec L03 requests representative windows with “100%, 125% and 150% browser zoom” (`spec.md:124`). Twelve actual browser-window/zoom cases satisfy that matrix; physical monitor/OS scaling coverage remains limited (`acceptance-results.md:19`).
- L16 original/reviewer isolation has real panel/style evidence, but the old acceptance artifact exposes zero media members. This does not establish loaded-media or end-to-end acceptance success; the report explicitly limits that claim.
Independent corroboration: final runner SHA-256 matches the documented `a20779d7…fa9f56`; raw `task08-runner-review-green5.log` records three generation/save/handoff cycles, two successful claims and one empty claim. Earlier interruptions remain disclosed. Baseline frontend/Go/Python failures are not new feature defects; no full-suite-green, quality approval or deployment claim is warranted.
Reviewed only documentation correction `b83e810e` and its report.
**Documented violation closed.** `.scratch/annotation-workspace-layout/map.md:34–41` now contains a linked resolution summary for each of tickets 01–08 within Decisions-so-far, satisfying `docs/agents/issue-tracker.md:31–32`. Current implementation status is explicit at lines 5 and 33; earlier design observations are clearly historical at lines 13, 44, 61, 65 and 81–83. Coverage limitations remain explicit at line 42. No residual finding in this correction.
Read-only verification confirmed all 18 local Markdown links resolve and all 8 tickets linked from Decisions-so-far contain `Status: resolved` and `## Answer`. No browser or test suites rerun; no Git mutations.
**Three low-priority advisories remain deferred, not fixed:** duplicated browser reachability helpers; page-size policy duplicated between pagination and the workbench; repeated viewport threshold predicates. The execution record documents separate reasons and future maintenance costs. These remain judgment calls, not documented-standard violations or demonstrated current functional failures.
Final Standards disposition: 0 open documented-standard violations; 3 deferred low-priority smell advisories. This scoped re-review does not replace the independent Spec-axis assessment.
Reviewed `git diff ee2e355ba1838578b0611628bc764abbbeec6eef...a313b22a`, including production, browser-test, ticket and evidence changes. No browser or broad test suites rerun. Findings below distinguish documented requirements from maintainability judgments.
**Documented-standard violation**
- **Resolution map omitted.** The new resolved-ticket hunks, e.g. `.scratch/annotation-workspace-layout/issues/01-focused-view-and-legacy-switch.md:33` and `issues/08-full-workflow-acceptance-and-guide.md:31`, add Answers and link *to* the map, but add no resolution summaries or ticket links *in* its Decisions-so-far section. `docs/agents/issue-tracker.md:31–32` explicitly requires all three resolution steps. `.scratch/annotation-workspace-layout/map.md:29–46` remains unchanged and still ends “没有开始改动产品代码”. Add concise resolution summaries and links there, and distinguish historical design statements from current implementation status. This is a documentation/workflow issue; no production standards breach found.
**Smell baseline — judgment calls, low priority**
- **Possible Duplicated Code:**`tests/browser/annotation-workspace-annotation.mjs:26`, `annotation-workspace-navigation.mjs:36`, `annotation-workspace-dictionaries.mjs:25` and `annotation-workspace-camera-inspection.mjs:62` copy viewport/hit-test assertions, including `e.contains(document.elementFromPoint(r.x + r.width / 2, r.y + r.height / 2))`. Copies already differ in positive-width/height checks. Share the reachability measurement/assertion so acceptance improvements apply consistently; retain scenario-specific assertions locally.
- **Possible Shotgun Surgery:**`src/components/TimelinePageNavigation.tsx:5` defines `const pageSize = 4`, while `src/components/CaptureAnnotationWorkbench.tsx:777` independently uses `pageContaining(slices, slice.id, 4)`. Changing the list policy requires coordinated edits outside its owner. Expose a reveal-by-ID operation on the pagination hook, or share the policy constant.
- **Possible Duplicated Code:**`src/pages/AnnotationOperations.tsx:522,529,533` repeats the focused-layout minimum predicate, including `window.innerWidth < 1280 || window.innerHeight < 640`. Extract the dimension predicate/constants while retaining fresh window reads at dispatch boundaries; otherwise render, suspension and dispatch eligibility can drift during future threshold changes.
Totals: 1 documented-standard violation; 3 low-priority smell judgments. No tooling-enforced findings or unrelated baseline cleanup requested.
Blocking a user prevents them from interacting with repositories, such as opening or commenting on pull requests or issues. Learn more about blocking a user.