8.6 KiB
Task 1 implementation report
Status
Implementation, focused automated verification, controller-owned browser/API acceptance, and read-only review are complete. The fix review approved the task with no Critical or Important findings.
Changes
- Added
src/lib/annotation-authoritative-mutation.jswith a generation-scoped task/account mutation fence, authoritative write settlement, semantic workspace matching, and reset reconciliation. - Updated
confirmAnnotationDescriptionso only a successful response or matching authoritative reread advances the item version and saved baseline. Removed the development-mode conflict success fallback. - Updated
resetToSliceEditingso only a successful response or an authoritative reset workspace clears descriptions and enters slice editing. Removed the development-mode conflict success fallback. - Failed writes reread the task. Mismatched or unreadable authority remains failed/unknown, retains editable content, and does not import a newer version for a blind overwrite retry.
- Task/account switches invalidate the mutation generation. Late responses and late
finallyblocks cannot update or unlock a newer workspace operation, including same-context ABA.
TDD evidence
RED:
node --test tests/frontend/annotation-authoritative-mutation.test.mjs
exit 1: ERR_MODULE_NOT_FOUND for src/lib/annotation-authoritative-mutation.js
GREEN cycle 1:
node --test tests/frontend/annotation-authoritative-mutation.test.mjs
6 passed, 0 failed
RED cycle 2:
node --test tests/frontend/annotation-authoritative-mutation.test.mjs
exit 1: module did not provide annotationWorkspaceMatches
GREEN cycle 2:
node --test tests/frontend/annotation-authoritative-mutation.test.mjs
8 passed, 0 failed
The regression tests exercise confirmed responses, response-loss recovery through GET, conflict/mismatch, unreadable authority, task/account switches, same-context ABA, server timing metadata, and reset-state proof. They assert behavior of the executable helper rather than source strings or private React state.
Verification evidence
node --test tests/frontend/annotation-authoritative-mutation.test.mjs tests/frontend/annotation-submission-state.test.mjs tests/frontend/annotation-operation-latency.test.mjs tests/frontend/annotation-operations.test.mjs
24 passed, 0 failed
go test ./internal/api -run 'Test(SliceResetClearsDescriptionsAndReturnsToEditing|AnnotationConfirmationRequiresMaterializedSlicesAndAcceptsSparseDescriptions|PendingCombinedSubmissionBlocksWorkspaceMutations|SliceResetPreservesRevisionFence)$' -count=1
ok droboticflow/internal/api
npm run lint:web
exit 0
npm run build:web
exit 0; Vite built 3,202 modules. Existing large-chunk advisory only.
npx prettier --check src/pages/AnnotationOperations.tsx src/lib/annotation-authoritative-mutation.js tests/frontend/annotation-authoritative-mutation.test.mjs tests/frontend/annotation-submission-state.test.mjs
exit 0
No full test suite was run, per ticket instructions.
Browser and HTTP evidence
Controller fixture:
- project
project-keyboard-acceptance - primary task
annotation-task-keyboard-acceptance-annotate-primary - delayed-response task
annotation-task-keyboard-acceptance-annotate-delayed - local frontend/API/Mongo only (
5173/3001/27018)
The first normal-save attempt exercised the real page and HTTP endpoint but was rejected because the isolated fixture stored segment timestamp fields as BSON Long-shaped objects ({high,low,unsigned}), which Go correctly rejected for int64. The captured request otherwise contained the expected version, three hardware-aligned slices, description, operations, and statuses. This was repaired only in the local fixture data.
After fixture repair, the real page successfully saved 键盘验收01:正常保存. A second save used the local fault proxy: the real API returned HTTP 200, the proxy destroyed the browser response, the page reread the task, matched the authoritative workspace, closed the editor, and displayed persisted text 键盘验收01:响应丢失后核对保存. Independent API readback returned version 3 and the intended text.
Conflict evidence: a public competing write advanced the primary item to version 4 with 键盘验收01:另一页面的新内容. The stale page description save returned HTTP 409, displayed the retained local draft, and did not report success. A stale reset also returned HTTP 409; its warning remained open and neither slices nor descriptions were cleared. API readback remained version 4 with the competing text.
Late-response evidence: the proxy held the primary save response for 30 seconds while the controller opened the delayed task and saved its own description. Releasing the old response did not inject the delayed task's content into the primary workspace or unlock the wrong operation. API readback showed the primary at version 5 with 键盘验收01:迟到保存应隔离 and the delayed task at version 2 with its own intended text.
Reset result-unknown evidence: primary reset reached the real API with HTTP 200 and the proxy destroyed the response. The page reread authority and reconciled to one full-range 0–412 slice with no descriptions. Independent API readback showed primary version 6, sliceWorkflow status editing, phase slice, and an empty descriptions array.
All browser actions used the real page through cua_repl; all writes targeted the isolated local fixture and local API/Mongo only.
Self-review
- The mutation fence compares task and account and also carries a monotonically increasing ID, so a late completion cannot own a newer operation after invalidation.
- Failed conflict reconciliation deliberately does not install the reread item version. Retrying with retained stale edits therefore cannot overwrite newer server content; explicit refresh is required.
- A response-loss recovery counts as success only when the reread version advanced and the authoritative semantic workspace matches the attempted write. Server-added hardware timestamp metadata does not affect the semantic match.
- Reset recovery requires a newer item version,
sliceWorkflowin reset editing state withresetAt, nonempty slices, and empty operations/descriptions. - Existing permissions, claim checks, dictionary fields, slice disposition, blank/invalid/discard semantics, and hardware-aligned boundaries remain in the original API handlers.
- The task-status edit and fixture preparation script are unrelated controller/fixture changes and are not staged.
Remaining gaps
- No ticket 01 implementation gaps remain. The controller repaired and API-verified the fixture project's dictionary linkage separately for later tickets; no application change was required.
Commit
18139a00 — 🛡️ Make annotation edit results authoritative
Fix round 1: synchronous context invalidation
The first read-only review found that task invalidation relied on a passive React effect. A response could theoretically settle after setSelectedTaskId was scheduled but before the effect ran. The fix adds a live authoritative mutation context that invalidates the generation synchronously before every selected-task state update. All task select, close, claim, automatic selection, pending-discard selection, and prepackage-preview paths now use that seam. Account identity is compared and switched during render, before passive account cleanup effects.
RED:
node --test tests/frontend/annotation-authoritative-mutation.test.mjs
exit 1: module did not provide createAuthoritativeMutationContext
GREEN and covering verification:
node --test tests/frontend/annotation-authoritative-mutation.test.mjs
9 passed, 0 failed
node --test tests/frontend/annotation-authoritative-mutation.test.mjs tests/frontend/annotation-submission-state.test.mjs tests/frontend/annotation-operation-latency.test.mjs tests/frontend/annotation-operations.test.mjs
25 passed, 0 failed
npm run lint:web
exit 0
npm run build:web
exit 0; existing large-chunk advisory only
The revised regression resolves a deferred response immediately after context.switchTo, without manually invalidating the scope or waiting for an effect. Separate task and account cases both settle as stale; the page calls that same context switch before scheduling selected-task state.
Fix commit: 61703abc — 🐛 Invalidate stale annotation writes synchronously.
The follow-up reviewer marked the original finding ADDRESSED, spec compliance Compliant, and task quality Approved, with no new Critical or Important issues. Review: .superpowers/sdd/annotation-keyboard-workflow/task-1-review-fix1.md.